Taxing social media in Africa

taxing-social-media
Photo by George Pagan III on Unsplash.

How much would you pay your government for a day’s worth of WhatsApp messaging?

One after another, the governments of three countries in Africa, Uganda, Zambia and Benin have announced or imposed new taxes on mobile internet customers in 2018, leaving millions of Africans struggling to cover the costs of getting online. Only in Benin did protests result in quick abandonment of the tax plan.

Governments have imposed these levies to raise public revenues, and also argue that they are protecting the local telecommunications sector from competition from internet companies from abroad. But in practice, the (intended or unintended) consequence has been to push more people offline, increase barriers to getting online, and vastly limit freedom of expression and access to information — as well as access to goods and services that are now online.

Uganda imposed the first of these tax schemes in July 2018, forcing residents to pay a daily tax of 200 shillings ($0.053 USD) to use any one of 58 “over the top” (OTT) mobile communication apps. These include — but are not limited to — social media services like Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, and LinkedIn; instant messaging and voice communication apps WhatsApp, Snapchat, Skype; and dating sites like Tinder and Grindr.

The law in Uganda also placed a 1% tax on the use of mobile money, which is now the required method for airtime top up of SIM cards. With the average Ugandan already spending 15% of their monthly income for 1GB of broadband data, the new tax puts popular internet services out of reach for most people.

This is not just a matter of chatting with friends. As anyone in the region knows, WhatsApp in particular has become an essential platform for communication and information-sharing in Africa. Millions of people rely on WhatsApp groups to conduct business, communicate about local issues, read the news, and seek help in emergencies.

For many Ugandans, social media like Facebook and WhatsApp are a gateway to the rest of the internet. In an opinion piece for Global Voices, Ugandan blogger Pru Nyamishana wrote:

“The tax ignores a critical lack of digital literacy, particularly among poor Ugandans. When I interviewed women living in Bwaise, a slum in Kampala, I learned that for them, WhatsApp and Facebook are the internet. These are the only platforms they know how to use. So with the new tax, they will be cut off altogether.”

After the tax had been in effect for six months, the Uganda Communications Commission reported national internet usage rates had dropped by from 47.4% to just 35%.

On the heels of Uganda’s initiative, Benin approved a similar tax in September 2018, targeting mobile messaging and ‘Voice over IP’ calls (like Skype). It drove up the cost of a single gigabyte of data by nearly 250% but was repealed just days later, in the face of public protests.

The Zambian government announced a flat daily tax of 30 ngwees (US $0.03) on IP-based voice calls in August. Despite pushback from civil society and Zambia’s Chamber of Commerce and Industry, government officials went ahead with the tax, arguing that it would raise public revenues, bolster local telecommunications enterprises, and help cover the cost of investments in infrastructure.

“Jobs such as call centre workers, talk time sellers, conventional call technicians will reduce drastically if more Zambians migrate to internet calls and create jobs in America and elsewhere,” tweeted Dora Siliya, Zambia’s Minister of Information and Broadcasting Services.

Although this reasoning rang hollow for many internet users, Siliya’s argument is consistent with longstanding frustrations on the continent about foreign-owned OTT services that have captured markets for messaging and voice calls, changing the game for national telecom operators.

Countries in Africa are not alone in resenting how the data and advertising-driven business models of big tech bring few immediate benefits to local economies, while enriching technology companies in the United States. Google and Facebook are increasingly now also in the infrastructure game which will affect the power balance with telcos even further. Meanwhile, it’s a fact that popular OTT services have helped fuel the uptake of mobile internet, and enabled local businesses to operate more efficiently. They have been critical to creating a virtuous cycle of record growth in internet use, network investments, and also telco profits.

In a region where governments are known for restricting free speech through censorship, internet shutdowns, surveillance and legal threats, civil society and independent media also view OTT tax schemes as an attack on free speech. In two other cases, this is clearly warranted.

In Tanzania, a so-called “blogger tax” was introduced in April 2018 alongside new restrictions for online content, in a clear effort to limit online expression. It requires Tanzanian bloggers, YouTube channel operators, and independent website owners to register and pay roughly $900 USD per year to publish online.

In August, the Mozambican government decreed that individual journalists and media outlets using both traditional and digital platforms now have to register and pay between $500 to $3,300 USD for an accreditation license that must be renewed every five years.

Taxes like these propagate the misconception that internet access and social media use are luxuries. But their outcomes — like the drop in internet use in Uganda — offer a compelling case study on the importance of establishing protections for net neutrality. What citizens have emphasized in protests, and what local researchers have also demonstrated, is that access to a truly open internet is a boon for local economies, education, public health and life in general.

Do social media taxes make sense to you?

  1. Scraperret

    Telegram Scraper Free Download

    What is Telegram Group Scraper ?
    Telegram Group Scraper is a software by which you can find active users for your Telegram Group. Trying to find members conventionally might take months to get a niche-based audience. But, when you use Telegram Scraper, you can find active members from your competitors without even spending a day. Besides that, Telegram Group Scraper complies with the TOS of Telegram as it uses Telegram API to find users. While using this software, you can customize your search settings and filter your users while you are uploading them. You can also save the details of these members as a CSV file.

    Why should you use Telegram Group Scraper?
    There are numerous benefits of using Telegram Group Scraper. However, it depends upon your purpose. If you have a small business and want to generate new leads, you can use this software to reach out to your target audience. By doing so, you can increase the click-through rate and enhance the number of sales.
    You can also use Telegram Group Scraper for promoting an event or your business. In a nutshell, this software would help you build your Telegram Group from scratch. It can also assist you in finding an active audience who would find your content as complying with their interests.

    What are the features of Telegram Scraper software?
    The main features of Telegram Group Scraper that you have to consider include:
    • By using this software, you can find active members who have a real interest in the products you are offering. Through this, you can grow your business without any hassle.
    • You can use Telegram Scraper to export members from other niche-based groups into a CSV file. You can use these details to add members to your Group.
    • You can make changes to the search settings, which would help you to filter the users. Through this, you can ensure that you are finding the right audience.
    • Even though you can only import 8000 members per day, you can export an unlimited number of users. You can use Telegram Group Scraper for this purpose. Instead of importing members to your Group, you can also use the details to send bulk messages.

    How to download Telegram Group Scraper Bot?
    You can download Telegram Group Scraper from here

    https://filehug.com/Telegramgroupscraper_2021.zip

    https://filerap.com/Telegramgroupscraper_2021.zip

    https://fileshe.com/Telegramgroupscraper_2021.zip

    Thank u

  2. Georgenop

    You need to market on Instagram, reach millions of potential customers...

    Follow by suggestion or uid
    Unfollow conditionally
    Interactive comment like by uid
    Post on the wall
    Schedule a daily run

    Playlist manual: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=doKRopt1PVQ&list=PLOlwy9jxkiDNn_2K5802Aek8iqz5qROjJ

    FUNCTIONS IN INSTAGRAMPLUS
    Theo dõi
    Follow suggestions
    Follow uid
    Follow uid's follower or following
    Follow the person who commented like the post
    Unfollow
    Unfollow under multiple conditions
    Find UID
    Find uid follow uid
    Find uid following of uid
    Find post comment uid
    Find uid like posts
    Interactive comment like
    Interactive comment like friends
    Interactive comment like list uid
    Interactive comment like people like comment posts
    Interactively comment like the follower or follower of uid
    Make a daily schedule
    Schedule follow-up according to suggestions
    Schedule follow uid
    Schedule unfollow
    Schedule posting on the wall

    Free Download Here:

    https://filehug.com/InstagramPlus.zip
    https://filerap.com/InstagramPlus.zip
    https://fileshe.com/InstagramPlus.zip

    Thank you

  3. Pedrotus

    Paigham Bot Full - The Leader In Lead Generation

    Download Here :

    https://filehug.com/PaighamBot_Full.zip

    https://filerap.com/PaighamBot_Full.zip

    https://fileshe.com/PaighamBot_Full.zip

    Paigham Bot is one of the most effective marketing applications on the market today. It is able to accurately gather data from search engines in any industry or niche and provides contact details for businesses and people that are most important to you i.e. YOUR MOST PRIZED PROSPECTS-AND WILL ALSO CONTACT THEM FOR YOU.
    Paigham Bot v9.1.6.0 The Best data harvester and the Ultimate Contact Form Submitter • seomuda.net
    Find Unlimited Lead Data
    Powerful audience identification process to identify targeted prospects with our advanced search filtering process. Find Websites, phone numbers, emails and social media accounts easily for almost any website or business. Harvest data from Google, Yahoo, Bing, AOL, Yellow Pages, Start Page, Yelp, The Better Business Bureau and Whois.com. Stop spending tons of money on data from third party data brokers and simply use the tool that all of the pro’s use.
    Mass/Bulk Marketing Solution
    Tired of only a 7-10% open rate with traditional email marketing campaigns? Our application fills out the contact form of your prospects website. These forms traditionally have a 90-95% open rate! The software also features a powerful email module and social media modules which allows you to email millions of people. Identify your audience with our Data Harvester, and Paigham Bot will automatically deliver a custom message to your targeted prospects getting you in touch with millions of people.

    Thank you

    Tags:
    paigham bot review
    paigham bot cracked
    paigham bot vs scrapebox
    paigham bot vs xrumer
    paigham bot vs gsa search engine ranker
    paigham bot crack
    paigham bot vs
    paigham bot proxy scraper & checker pro

  4. TheresaNag

    It is remarkable, this very valuable message

    circumspection
    pussy orgasm torture

  5. MarioSLoda

    lasix dosage generic lasix - lasix for sale

  6. Williamvioms

    Hello World!!!
    http://www.comptine.biz/modules.php?name=Your_Account&op=userinfo&username=IGGMarcy06
    http://audiofilipino.org/__media__/js/netsoltrademark.php?d=cafekelaas.com%2Fforums%2Fusers%2Fcassandralowell%2F
    https://dailycourier.gatespolls.com/2021/05/10/wike-reviews-curfew-compensates-slain-police-officers/
    http://www.sanantoniochamberofcommerce.net/__media__/js/netsoltrademark.php?d=lomeit.tg%2Fforums%2Fusers%2Flinneafairfax%2F
    http://www.backpacks.sblinks.net/user/zoraburchf/
    http://www.hawavalves.de/__media__/js/netsoltrademark.php?d=fagorautomation.us%2Fforums%2Fusers%2Fpatsythrelfall%2Fedit%2F%3Fupdated%3Dtrue%2Fusers%2Fpatsythrelfall%2F
    https://aktieraktier.netlify.app/6959/52653.html
    http://cacaboudin.com/__media__/js/netsoltrademark.php?d=tabletopboardgames.us%2Fforums%2Fusers%2Fjeannastatton13%2F
    http://www.computers.sbm.pw/News/find-more-info-164/
    https://vwiin.com/forum/profile.php?id=645457

    930730964
    http://41136395.footblogology.info/article?id=257967116
    http://749441369.visualit.pl/article?id=?615049309
    http://832751312.sumpom.pw/article?id=?587730582
    http://383579069.dogfootblog.info/article?id=?671996490
    http://268351813.redfootblog.info/article?id=?599226130
    http://690582450.alicjaexclusive.pl/article?id=?295105887
    http://922986317.brakim.se/article?id=?956706074
    http://630418183.murakamisenseiseminar.pl/article?id=?982148091
    http://455504566.szkoleniabrwi.pl/article?id=?737097294
    http://788846380.stomatolog-awdiejew.pl/article?id=?392614203
    http://895666898.ogioth.fun/article?id=?318644222

  7. hydroxychloroquine for sale for humans

    hydroxychloroquine for sale for humans

    Taxing social media in Africa — The Internet Health Report 2019

  8. hydroxychloroquine youtube video

    hydroxychloroquine success rate

    seed antispasmodic drugs jump

  9. ordering hydroxychloroquine online

    who profits from hydroxychloroquine

    resort borborygmi imply

  10. BrendanSic

    ed pills online pharmacy: medications for - soma therapy ed

  11. BrendanSic

    canadian drug prices: medications list - ed online pharmacy

  12. Daviddug

    http://ivermectinstr.online# stromectol pills

  13. pharmaceptica.com

    is erectile dysfunction reversible https://pharmaceptica.com/

  14. shortage of hydroxychloroquine

    erectile growing foods https://plaquenilx.com/ - hydroxychloroquine acheter bladder cancer erectile beefs function buy hydroxychloroquine online

  15. hydroxychloroquine where to buy

    what does hydroxychloroquine treat https://hydroxychloroquinex.com/# - interactions for hydroxychloroquine hydroxychloroquine sulfate side effects methotrexate

  16. online casino games

    casino slots https://playcasinovivo.com/# online casinos casino online slots

  17. buy hydroxychloroquine online

    malaria skin rash https://chloroquineorigin.com/# - chloroquine malaria what is chloroquine used for

  18. tadalafil 30 mg

    tadalaf https://tadalisxs.com/ elevex tadalafil 20mg

  19. order zithromax

    zepak antibiotics https://zithromaxes.com/ zithromax wiki

  20. Youth, Citizenship and African Governance – Debating Development Research

    […] down when the invasion of Tigray took place ). Governments also seek to curb youth protests by imposing social media taxes and stricter control of internet-based […]

  21. Anonymous

    A protectionist measure might be good, but they should tax the companies but not the people.

  22. Mozilla и Tor: В защиту анонимности | Alex Semёnov

    […] повторилась в Уганде, где власти ввели специальный налог на использование социальных […]

  23. Africa Telecoms Infrastructure in 2019 | Many Possibilities

    […] generated from taxation of the sector. Unfortunately, Benin, Tanzania, Zambia, and others have followed suit with variations on this theme. Sadly, those who suffer most from a user tax on social media are the […]

  24. Taxing dissent: Uganda's social media dilemma - Global Voices Advox

    […] Poor, marginalized groups continue to be hit hardest.   […]

  25. From Paris to Dakar: Launch of the Internet Health Report in French – Home

    […] are the slowest and where the cost of connectivity is the least affordable. It’s where where social media is taxed in several countries, where women connect at far lower rates than men, and where internet […]

  26. James B

    It sounds like this is being sold as a protectionist measure, but it's not clear from the article if local (national, or at least African) services would be exempted. If the purpose of the tax is to act as a tariff that opens a space for African messaging services, reasonable people could hold views on either side. But it's hard to believe that's what's happening here. It sounds like an attempt at censorship (in some cases) and a regressive money-grab that disproportionately hurts those who are just starting to climb the ladder of prosperity.

  27. Maciej

    In European Union internet access is subject to basic rate (the highest) of VAT. Why should be surprised that other governments consider it not a necessity?

  28. Jamshed

    In India we have to pay general taxes to obtain talk time on mobile phones. We also pay a tax on the use of internet connections for our desk tops, tablets, and miscellaneous gadgets. Is this not a violation of our freedom? On one side we talk of going digital and on the other we increase taxes / revenue streams for digital service providers / government this being a ridiculous and retrograde step.

  29. Zoracon

    I notice in gaming online I rarely see anyone from the African continent (maybe SA at times) online to play. And it makes sense now as to why. Restrictive governments imposing lack of access. It's not that just that the people are "too poor". This is a deliberate attack on access to the rest of the continent and the world.

  30. LouwN

    Ridiculous and preposterous and two steps back. For shame.

See Mozilla Community Participation guidelines: [English | Español | Deutsch | Français]. This is a moderated comment space. We will remove comments that are offensive or completely off topic.